Juvenile criminal justice: Towards regulation in Latin America

October 31, 2018
Communications Colunga Foundation

The Ibero-American Center for the Rights of the Child (CIDENI) held an international conference together with expert academics in determining sanctions for young offenders.

For months, CIDENI worked with academics from Mexico, Costa Rica, Peru, Spain and Brazil, to know the situation of these countries, in relation to how sanctions are determined to young people who have committed a crime, what are their criteria and associated standards .

These experiences were presented at an international conference that included the participation of specialists from these five countries, representatives of different public entities linked to the Chilean criminal system and the principal investigators of CIDENI, Jaime Couso and Miguel Cillero.

"The question is whether the system is capable of condemning those who break the law, of integrating people who are 15, 16 or 17 years old into society and not simply forgetting them in prisons. In CIDENI we work to generate knowledge and practices that serve precisely to improve policies, legislation or programs aimed at children, especially the poorest of our countries, "he says. Miguel Cillero, President of CIDENI.

"We tried to be super strategic in the invitation, we did not want this to be a hyper academic instance, but also to have an impact, which is what CIDENI seeks, to reach public policies and legislation," Ester Valenzuela, Executive Director of the center.

This conference and alliance aims to generate the bases to build a model regulation in Latin America in adolescent criminal matters, which is a reduction of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. "The Convention is tremendously virtuous. Next year marks 30 years of its creation, however, in terms of juvenile criminal responsibility, it has weaknesses. There is a lack of greater clarity and depth ", explains Ester.

Although it is one of the most ratified treaties, there are still major differences in the determination of sanctions against adolescents who have broken the law between countries. For example, in Chile, our legislation considers a maximum limit of 5 years of hospitalization for offenders under 16, and 10 years for adolescents between 16 and 18 years, while Brazil establishes a maximum of three years for adolescents between 12 and 18 years old; Mexico contemplates a maximum length of stay of 3 years for adolescents between 14 and 15 years and 5 years for those between 16 and 18 years.

The final document, which will be made available to judges and justice operators, is scheduled for mid-next year.

Últimos comunicados

Inédito estudio evidencia la compleja realidad post penitenciaria en mujeres

Nueva charla de #TiemposDeDiálogo explica metodología de geologías de paz para la transformación social

Colunga anuncia capacitaciones sobre diálogo y transformación de conflictos destinadas a organizaciones de la sociedad civil